A Contemplation on Avicenna’s Arguments on Immateriality of the Soul
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.58355/maqolat.v3i1.122Keywords:
Soul, immateriality, AvicennaAbstract
Abstract
Total intellectual immateriality of rational soul is one of the major subjects in philosophy and anthropology among Muslims, especially Avicenna. Avicenna has provided several arguments to prove the intellectual immateriality of rational soul, using the position and insensibility of intelligible forms, the unlimited power of the soul in the perception of intelligible forms, and rational soul being needless of physical tools in some of its perceptions. In the present study, the mentioned arguments are explored and criticized, demonstrating that they cannot prove the total intellectual immateriality of the rational soul, that is, its complete lack of matter and the properties of matter (volume and mass). Therefore, other points of view about the rational soul - for example, those of Mulla Sadra Shirazi -which state the materiality of the soul at the time of its creation and its subsequent immateriality as a result of substantial motion- should be recruited.
Downloads
References
Al-Ash’ari, Abu Al-Hasan, 1963, Maqalat al-Islamiyyin WA Ikhtilaf al-Musallin. Edited by Ritter Helmut. Wiesbaden, Germany: Franz Steiner publishing house
Aristotle, 1987, On the soul. Translated by: Davoudi Alimorad. Tehran: Hekmat Press
Avicenna, Hussein bin Abdullah, no date. Al-ta’liqat. Badvi Abdulrahman. Qum: Islamic Media Office
Avicenna, Hussein bin Abdullah, 1979, Al-Rasael. Qum: Bidar publishing house
Avicenna, Hussein bin Abdullah, 1983, Al-Ilahiyat min al-Shifa (Al-nafs). Zayed Saeid. Qum: Al-Marashi al-Najafi Library
Avicenna, Hussein bin Abdullah, 1985, Meraj-nameh. Mayel-heravi Najib. Mashhad: Astan Quds Razavi Islamic Research Foundation
Avicenna, Hussein bin Abdullah, 1991, Al-mobahesat. Bidarfar, Mohsen. Qum: Bidar publishing house
Avicenna, Hussein bin Abdullah, 1996 A, Al-Shifa': al-Nafs. Hasanzade-amoli Hasan. Qum: Islamic Media Office
Avicenna, Hussein bin Abdullah, 1996 B, al-Isharat WA al-Tanbihat. Annotated by: Tusi, Nasir al-Din. Qom: Nashr al-Balagha
Avicenna, Hussein bin Abdullah, 2004, Kitāb al-Nafs. Amid, Musa. Hamedan: Bu-ali-sina University publishing
Avicenna, Hussein bin Abdullah, 2006, Al-Nejat Wa-Al-Ilahiyah. Translated by: Yasrebi, Seyyed Yahya. Qum: Boostan-e-Ketab Publishing
Copleston, Fredrick, 2001, History of Philosophy, Translated by Mojtabavi, Seyyed Jalalaldin. Tehran: Soroush Scientific and cultural press
Fayyazi, Gholamreza, 2014, Philosophical self-knowledge. Yousefi, Mohammad Taqi. Qum: Imam-Khomeini Institute
Ghazali, Abu Hamed, 2003; Tahfut al-Falasifa. Donya, Soleiman. Tehran: Shams Tabrizi press.
Helli, Hasan Ibn Yousef, 1992; Al-Jawhar al-Nazid. Bidarfar, Mohsen. Qum: Bidar –Helli Publishing House.
Mortaza, Seyyed, 1984, Javabat Al-Masail al-Razieh Fi Rasalat Al-Mortaza. Introduction by: Alhosaini Ahmad. Qum: Darol-quran Press
Mo’tazeli, Abdul-Jabbar, 1965, Kitāb Al-Mughnī Fī Abwāb Al-Tawḥīd WA Al-'Adl. Egypt: Egyptian General Corporation
Mesbah Yazdi, Mohammad Taqi, 1987, Tteaching philosophy. Tehran: Islamic Advertisement Organization
Mofid, Mohammad Ibn Nu’man, 1993, Al-Masayil Al-Sarawia. Saeb, Abdolhamid. Qum: Sheikh Al-Mufid International Conference
Plato, 1987, Plato complete works. Translated by: Lotfi, Mohammad Hasan, Kaviani R. Tehran: Kharazmi publishing group
Plotinus, 1987, Complete works. Translated by: Lotfi, Mohammad Hasan. Tehran: Sahami press
Qavam safari, Mehdi, 2003, Theory of form in Aristotle philosophy. Tehran: Hekmat Press
Razi, Fakhr al-Din, 1990, Al-Mabahes Al-Mashreqyah. Qum: Bidar Publishing House
Saduq al-Shaykh, 1984, Al-I’tiqadat. Qum: Manshoorat Razi
Sha’rani A, no date, Sharh Tajrid al-I’tiqad. Tehran: Islamiyah press
Shirazi, Sadr al-Din Mohammad (Mulla Sadra), 1981, Al-Hikma al-Mota’liah. Beirut: Daralahiya al-Tarath press
Tabatabai, Seyyed Mohammad Hussein, 1985, Essentials of philosophy and realism. Introduction by: Motahari Mortaza. Qum: Sadra press
Tabatabai, Seyyed Mohammad Hussein, 1993, Al-Mizan Fi Tafsir Al-Quran. Tehran: Dar-Al-Kotob Al-Islamiah
Tabatabai, Seyyed Mohammad Hussein, 2007, Nahayat Al-Hikma. Translated by Fayyazi Gholamreza. Qum: Imam-Khomeini institute
Tusi, Nasir al-Din, 1992, Tajrid Al-I’tiqad. Helli, Hasan Ibn Yousef. Qum: Islamic Publishing House
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Bahador Mehraki
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
